Engineers Garage

  • Projects and Tutorials
    • Electronic Projects
      • 8051
      • Arduino
      • ARM
      • AVR
      • PIC
      • Raspberry pi
      • STM32
    • Tutorials
    • Circuit Design
    • Project Videos
    • Components
  • Articles
    • Tech Articles
    • Insight
    • Invention Stories
    • How to
    • What Is
  • News
    • Electronic Products News
    • DIY Reviews
    • Guest Post
  • Forums
    • EDABoard.com
    • Electro-Tech-Online
    • EG Forum Archive
  • Digi-Key Store
    • Cables, Wires
    • Connectors, Interconnect
    • Discrete
    • Electromechanical
    • Embedded Computers
    • Enclosures, Hardware, Office
    • Integrated Circuits (ICs)
    • Isolators
    • LED/Optoelectronics
    • Passive
    • Power, Circuit Protection
    • Programmers
    • RF, Wireless
    • Semiconductors
    • Sensors, Transducers
    • Test Products
    • Tools
  • EE Resources
    • DesignFast
    • LEAP Awards
    • Oscilloscope Product Finder
    • White Papers
    • Webinars
  • EE Learning Center
  • Women in Engineering

RFID vs Barcodes

By Ashutosh Bhatt

As far back as 1960s, the barcodes were used in industrial work environments. In the early 1970s, common barcodes started appearing on grocery shelves. To automate the process of identifying grocery items, UPC barcodes were placed on products and were used to mechanize the process of checking out in store. They are in use today also for allotment, supply chain, retail stores, apparel shops, book stores, movie galleries and libraries etc.

 
RFID is also in use since 1990, to find out the friend and foe military airplanes. Its use in supply chain management is the new concept. The RFID based Electronic Product Code (EPC) are much in use because in Barcode technology an optical reader is required to read the data manually while in RFID based EPC, data is read through the radio signals from the RFID tag with an RF reader automatically.
 
RFID tags can even be implanted in human and animal bodies. They work efficiently across visually and environmental challenging conditions such as human body, paint, smoke, fog, snow ice, and other, where barcodes and other optically read technologies do not work.

 

For RFID tags to replace barcodes they must present a convincing value scheme at reasonable cost. Some of the advantages of RFID tags over barcodes are associated with the ability to store information in the tags which is dynamic i.e. can be updated as and when required. They do not require line of sight for readouts and the tags can be read in a multiplexed fashion. Since the RFID tags contains memory elements and in barcodes the information is only printed in some sort of codes so the amount of information which can be stored in RFID is significantly greater than barcodes.
 
RFID tags have ability to incorporate additional functionalities like environmental monitoring of temperature, humidity, pressure through implanted circuitry. This functionality is not available with barcodes and the information stored is also static.
 
Despite of all the above advantages of RFID over Barcodes, they also have some disadvantages because of which barcodes are still in existence.
 
Firstly, Bar codes are printed directly on the paper or plastic objects. Henceforth implementing an Barcode system if far cheaper than the RFID technology.
 
Secondly, RFID functions like a wireless network so the system may have areas with weak signals. It’s also possible that the system may experience intervention from other source signals. Weak signals and obstruction from other sources might damage an RFID tracking system which is not the case with barcodes.
 
Thirdly, the RFID system is not restricted to line-of-sight which means malicious high-intensity directional antennas could be used to scan susceptible tags. Scam is always an opportunity when the technology is used for high-security operations, such as payment authentication.
 
Fourthly, a bar code can be put on an any object regardless of whether it is RF- lucent or RF-opaque. RFID tags can be read with difficulty if they are placed on metal and some liquids in UHF and microwave frequency ranges. Therefore, if an atmosphere has too much metal in it, an RFID system might not work well.
 
Fifthly, Bar code technology works on optics principles, whereas RFID technology works on the principle of RF waves. There are no restrictions on frequency of light, but are there on RF waves. Extensively varying global limits apply on RFID system frequency ranges.
Lastly, increasing RFID technology uptake also depends on standardization of the society.

 

 


Filed Under: How to
Tagged With: barcodes, rfid
 

Questions related to this article?
👉Ask and discuss on EDAboard.com and Electro-Tech-Online.com forums.



Tell Us What You Think!! Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

HAVE A QUESTION?

Have a technical question about an article or other engineering questions? Check out our engineering forums EDABoard.com and Electro-Tech-Online.com where you can get those questions asked and answered by your peers!


Featured Tutorials

  • Adjustable 0 to 30V 2A DC Power Supply Circuit (Part 1/13)
  • Adjustable +/- 1.25V to +/-22V 1A Power Supply Circuit (Part 2/13)
  • Adjustable 0 to 15V 1A Mini Power Supply (Part 3/13)
  • Constant 12V Power Supply for LED Circuits (Part 4/13)
  • Constant +/-9V DC Symmetrical Power Supply Circuit (Part 5/13)
  • Making a Circuit Breaker (Part 6/13)

Stay Up To Date

Newsletter Signup

Sign up and receive our weekly newsletter for latest Tech articles, Electronics Projects, Tutorial series and other insightful tech content.

EE Training Center Classrooms

“ee

“ee

“ee

“ee

“ee

“ee

Recent Articles

  • STMicroelectronics outlines path to $20B+ revenue
  • STMicroelectronics and MACOM announce successful RF GaN-on-Si prototypes
  • Infineon expands its CoolSiC portfolio
  • STMicroelectronics and AWS collaborate for secure IoT connections
  • Pet feeding system using WhatsApp (protocol bridging with MQTT)

Most Popular

5G 555 timer circuit 8051 ai Arduino atmega16 automotive avr dc motor display Electronic Part Electronic Parts Fujitsu ic infineontechnologies integratedcircuit Intel IoT ir lcd ldr led maximintegratedproducts microchip microchiptechnology Microchip Technology microcontroller microcontrollers mosfet motor powermanagement Raspberry Pi remote renesaselectronics Research robot samsung semiconductor sensor software STMicroelectronics switch Technology vishayintertechnology wireless

RSS EDABOARD.com Discussions

  • Space Vector PWM Help Needed
  • RFIC LNA cascode base and ground layout problem
  • Unable to launch virtuoso: libvisadev.so error
  • DIY test leads - source for lead ends?
  • P-Channel MOSFET always on

RSS Electro-Tech-Online.com Discussions

  • Voltage Regulator 12 - 5volt
  • How do I test amplifier speaker output polarity?
  • Adding Current Limit Feature to a Buck Converter
  • How to get lots of PCBs made cheap?
  • 24v dc relays not de-energising
Engineers Garage
  • Analog IC TIps
  • Connector Tips
  • DesignFast
  • EDABoard Forums
  • EE World Online
  • Electro-Tech-Online Forums
  • Microcontroller Tips
  • Power Electronic Tips
  • Sensor Tips
  • Test and Measurement Tips
  • 5G Technology World
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise

Copyright © 2022 WTWH Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of WTWH Media
Privacy Policy | Advertising | About Us

Search Engineers Garage

  • Projects and Tutorials
    • Electronic Projects
      • 8051
      • Arduino
      • ARM
      • AVR
      • PIC
      • Raspberry pi
      • STM32
    • Tutorials
    • Circuit Design
    • Project Videos
    • Components
  • Articles
    • Tech Articles
    • Insight
    • Invention Stories
    • How to
    • What Is
  • News
    • Electronic Products News
    • DIY Reviews
    • Guest Post
  • Forums
    • EDABoard.com
    • Electro-Tech-Online
    • EG Forum Archive
  • Digi-Key Store
    • Cables, Wires
    • Connectors, Interconnect
    • Discrete
    • Electromechanical
    • Embedded Computers
    • Enclosures, Hardware, Office
    • Integrated Circuits (ICs)
    • Isolators
    • LED/Optoelectronics
    • Passive
    • Power, Circuit Protection
    • Programmers
    • RF, Wireless
    • Semiconductors
    • Sensors, Transducers
    • Test Products
    • Tools
  • EE Resources
    • DesignFast
    • LEAP Awards
    • Oscilloscope Product Finder
    • White Papers
    • Webinars
  • EE Learning Center
  • Women in Engineering